Browserbase vs Browserless: handing off logins, sessions, and files after a report download disconnects

Browserbase suits sequential tasks centered on managed file handoffs and troubleshooting. Browserless offers distinct paths for short reconnections, persistent sessions, and authentication snapshots. Selection should test disconnect recovery, expired authentication, and repeated exports, rather than treating saved logins or session replay as resumable execution.

Source: docs.browserbase.com
November 16, 2026
7 min

An operations colleague exports a daily report from a supplier portal they are authorized to access. The script disconnects just after clicking “Generate report.” Whoever takes over needs to know: can they reconnect to the original page? Will tomorrow require another login? Did the file actually download? Browserbase and Browserless both provide remote browser infrastructure, but these questions concern different things: a live session, persistent authentication data, and the business task record.

Evaluate Browserbase first if you want Contexts, cloud downloads, and visual troubleshooting in one managed workflow. If you already have Puppeteer or Playwright workflows and need to choose explicitly between brief reconnections, state across runs, and separate authentication snapshots, Browserless provides more distinct paths, while requiring the team to keep the interfaces straight. This article draws on official documentation. It covers ordinary report downloads only from owned or authorized portals, not bypassing access restrictions or automatically solving CAPTCHAs. No real login or download tests were performed.

What to save for tomorrow’s run

Browserbase Contexts preserve login and application data from the Chromium user data directory, including cookies, localStorage, and IndexedDB. A new session needs the Context ID. To write changes back, set persist: true when creating it. Data is saved when the session closes, and you should wait a few seconds for synchronization before reusing it. The documentation recommends a separate Context for each login on each site and avoiding simultaneous use of the same Context, which can cause logout.

The handoff record should therefore distinguish Context ID from session ID: the former lets a new browser load saved data; the latter identifies a particular run. A framework’s BrowserContext object, persistent data, and a running browser are different things. An existing Context does not guarantee valid authentication: the portal can expire cookies, revoke tokens, or require authentication again. Passing MFA once does not imply a permanent exemption.

The Session API in Browserless’s current v2 documentation lets cookies, localStorage, and cache survive browser restarts. ttl controls the lifetime of the data. With the default processKeepAlive: 0, connecting again after disconnecting starts a new process on a blank page, so navigation must be repeated. Open pages and other live state survive only within a grace period while the process remains alive; this process keep-alive feature is limited to Puppeteer. A persistent session allows only one connected client at a time and should not be treated as a shared multi-user workspace.

Another option is Authenticated Profiles: save a snapshot of cookies, localStorage, and IndexedDB and load an independent copy into each session. SessionStorage is excluded. Changes during a run do not automatically update the original profile. This suits multiple authorized tasks reusing an authenticated starting point, rather than sharing the same report page. Decide in advance who updates the snapshot after authentication is refreshed.

Which browser must survive a return a few minutes later?

Browserbase keepAlive keeps the same session available for reconnection after a disconnect and is available only on paid plans. Release it explicitly when work ends; otherwise, it runs until timeout and incurs idle browser usage. It handles brief handoffs rather than replacing Context persistence across sessions.

Browserless Standard Sessions require obtaining a reconnect endpoint before disconnecting. The current dedicated documentation limits this path to Puppeteer. The waiting window is also capped by the plan’s maximum session duration measured from the original start, so repeated reconnections cannot extend it indefinitely. Each reconnection is billed as a new connection, and the waiting browser still occupies a concurrency slot. Playwright teams should design around the persistent-state documentation instead of copying Puppeteer’s disconnect semantics.

Scheduling also needs to distinguish a person waiting for the browser from a browser waiting for a person. A short-lived session may be kept while a report is generated. For work deferred overnight, prioritize saving necessary data and business checkpoints. Otherwise, idle connections consume resources and the next colleague may receive an already expired address. The task scheduler should record expiration and cleanup responsibilities; a replay screenshot cannot do that work.

This determines how the two shifts’ scripts divide responsibility. A brief network interruption may allow reconnection to a still-valid session. If the browser has ended, read the business checkpoint and reopen the report list instead of blindly clicking “Generate” again. Neither provider can guarantee exactly-once execution in the business system merely through browser reconnection.

Replay explains failures; the file is the deliverable

Browserbase’s download documentation says files are stored in the cloud and retrieved through the API, with a timestamp appended to filenames to reduce conflicts. Logging a click is insufficient: check the retrieved file’s report date, size, and contents. Browserless’s file transfer documentation offers a CDP path that delivers file bytes after download events are enabled, and demonstrates Download.saveAs over a native Playwright connection. Register listeners before triggering a download. When choosing the connection method, establish how files reach your team’s own storage.

Browserbase’s current session replay supports per-tab HLS playback and provides access to recording downloads. Browserless Session Replay is enabled with replay=true and records DOM changes and other events, unlike screen recording that returns WebM. Both help identify a wrong date selection or a stalled step. Watching a recording, however, neither restores a vanished process nor automatically retrieves a missing download.

A handoff should link the task ID, report scope, export status, file verification results, and session record. Replays may contain business-page information, and authentication data can grant account access. Limit access and retention, and do not paste token-bearing connection URLs into ordinary tickets.

Validate the handoff before choosing deployment

Consider a hypothetical acceptance test: download daily reports for 3 consecutive days using the same authorized account. On day one, interrupt after clicking “Generate”; the replacement script first checks the portal’s export history. On day two, end the browser and reload persistent data, confirm the correct account, and navigate again. On day three, deliberately invalidate authentication and verify that the task pauses for the account owner to authenticate instead of retrying forever. On every day, check the file date, nonempty content, and task ID; use existing export records and file verification to deduplicate reruns. This is an acceptance-test design, not a completed reliability test.

Separate the automation layer from infrastructure as well. Stagehand provides natural-language actions, extraction, and programmatic control interfaces. It is not the whole Browserbase service, and choosing it does not automatically resolve ownership of sessions, files, and reruns. A download script with stable selectors need not become an AI agent just to use a cloud browser.

Browserless’s self-hosting documentation distinguishes the basic Docker image from Enterprise features. Do not assume cloud replay, BrowserQL, and other capabilities all come standard in the free image. The repository LICENSE offers SSPL or a commercial license and explicitly flags commercial-license requirements for closed-source commercial applications and continuous integration. A self-hosting evaluation must also include browser upgrades, capacity, storage, and security maintenance, rather than comparing a cloud bill solely with the price of one server.

In short, teams running sequential downloads for one account and prioritizing managed file handoffs and troubleshooting can validate Browserbase first. Teams reusing existing clients, distinguishing profiles from persistent sessions, or genuinely able to self-host can validate Browserless first. If the portal already offers an authorized report API or scheduled delivery, evaluate that less page-state-dependent route first. The acceptance criterion is being able to explain where every file came from after disconnects, expiration, and reruns.

Content note:This article is based on publicly available information and is intended as a reference for evaluating tools. Features, pricing, and related policies may change at any time; please refer to the latest official information.

Original source:docs.browserbase.com